Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

I think he could be good depth and could replace Godfrey if he chose to follow Gregg Williams to Jacksonville. Im not sure what he would be worth although im sure many will guess "Vet Minimum". What do you guys think?

[url=http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d806c186a&template=with-video&confirm=true]Niners cut longtime leading tackler Smith[/url]

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

linebacker speed which is an empahsis right now would take a huge hit and second smith is a mlb and a runstopper not a quick and agile mlb like we have now that fits the mold for a team that likes to execute the tampa 2 defense.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

Smith is still playing? Wow. See now this is a guy that you can get for the veteran minimum.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

Are you some kind of comedian Smooter?

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

he was horrible the first time. now he is older and slower. no way.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

[QUOTE=wilsowilso;424079]Are you some kind of comedian Smooter?[/QUOTE]

Yeah I guess I accidentally omitted the lol at the end of my post. Like the title says: "Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?" and thats all you can come up with. Next time i'll make sure to put a knock knock joke in my post for you.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

No way is he worth signing he's real slow and old. I would say he is past his prime but he never was really at one.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

he's probably going to retire. he was already saying this was his last contract the day he signed it with the 49ers.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

[quote=Smooter;424106]Yeah I guess I accidentally omitted the lol at the end of my post. Like the title says: "Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?" and thats all you can come up with. Next time i'll make sure to put a knock knock joke in my post for you.[/quote]

So you were actually being serious about Derek Smith? My bad. Signing Derek Smith would be a laughable acquisition. IMO.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

screw smith, screw overpayed briggs, we need lavar arrington back on our side

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

Derek Smith is probably going to retire. I don't think, at his age, that he could help our depth in the middle.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

Lavar for the minimum, Lavar for the minimum -- Derek Smith hell NO

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

If I had to choose, I would take Smith over Arrington. Give it up folks, LA is done.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

This is the worst thread in the history of threads...

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

[QUOTE=dmek25;424080]he was horrible the first time. now he is older and slower. no way.[/QUOTE]


Typical example of your yesterday thread on waived/released players.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

I'm surprised it took as long as it did for this thread to show up...

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

In a word - - NO

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

[QUOTE=sportscurmudgeon;424270]In a word - - NO[/QUOTE]

What he said.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

[quote=oldhog44;424230]This is the worst thread in the history of threads...[/quote]


Trust me there have been worse

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

No way. He is too old. We don't need someone who has the age issue and could have injury issues down the road hindering our LB corps. Besides blades and campbell or any other rookie that they could get off the street would be better from the stand point of longevity. I don't think that Derrick Smith would be the right fit for us.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

Derek Smith is reunited with Norvell........nice move norv? :doh: THE END.

[url=http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/7836652/Bolts-agree-to-deal-with-linebacker-Smith]FOX Sports on MSN - NFL - Bolts agree to deal with linebacker Smith[/url]

POSTED 4:42 p.m. EST, February 24, 2008

SMITH LANDS IN SAN DIEGO

Well, we'll have to take Derek Smith out of the official PFT dumpster.

The veteran linebacker signed a contract on Sunday with the Chargers, less than a week after being cut by the 49ers.

Smith had spent seven seasons in San Fran. As a reader pointed out to us, he originally was drafted by the Redskins in 1997, at a time when Chargers coach Norv Turner was the head coach in D.C.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

there is no such thing as a stupid question just stupid people with questions that are never asked...

I would not be interested in Smith but he would be a better pick-up than some smart ass wanna be bad ass who turned out to be a dud!...I mean Lavar.

I got carried away!

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

OMG I'm so glad I was able to break this news. [URL="http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d806dca72&template=without-video&confirm=true"]Chargers sign linebacker Smith to two-year deal[/URL]

YES I AM THE FASTEST NEWS BREAKER THIS WORLD HAS TO OFFER! I POST LINKS BEFORE THE SITES EVEN PUTS THEM UP

By the way, whats with all the Derick Smith hate? He was a pretty decent player while he was here and he started for the 49ers for seven years, including the years where they were going to the playoffs. Next time do a background check before saying stupid stuff like "he sucked!"

Don't believe me, then see what ESPN had to say about the guy:
[URL="http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=3253440"]ESPN - With emergence of Willis, 49ers release longtime leading tackler Smith - NFL[/URL]
[B]"Smith has long been one of the NFL's top unsung defensive players, annually racking up gaudy tackling statistics with little fanfare. [/B]

And whats with all these injury issues? The guy has missed 9 games in 10 seasons. Maybe his bodies breaking down but hes not a guy I would consider injury prone.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

He is a Charger, and I actually did not see any reason for us to pursue him anyway.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

[QUOTE=Dirtbag359;425686]OMG I'm so glad I was able to break this news. [URL="http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d806dca72&template=without-video&confirm=true"]Chargers sign linebacker Smith to two-year deal[/URL]

YES I AM THE FASTEST NEWS BREAKER THIS WORLD HAS TO OFFER! I POST LINKS BEFORE THE SITES EVEN PUTS THEM UP

By the way, whats with all the Derick Smith hate? He was a pretty decent player while he was here and he started for the 49ers for seven years, including the years where they were going to the playoffs. Next time do a background check before saying stupid stuff like "he sucked!"

Don't believe me, then see what ESPN had to say about the guy:
[URL="http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=3253440"]ESPN - With emergence of Willis, 49ers release longtime leading tackler Smith - NFL[/URL]
[B]"Smith has long been one of the NFL's top unsung defensive players, annually racking up gaudy tackling statistics with little fanfare. [/B]

And whats with all these injury issues? The guy has missed 9 games in 10 seasons. Maybe his bodies breaking down but hes not a guy I would consider injury prone.[/QUOTE]

Someone's faster

[url]http://www.redskinswarpath.com/425624-post21.html[/url]

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

that dude got cut by the 49ers, hellll no.. he tackles like wet noodles

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

Maybe he can carry the watter bottle or something but other than that hell no, I'd rather sign a undrafted free agent who is young and has potential to be great or at least decent. That guy will just get older and suckier.

Re: Is former 'skin Derek Smith worth signing?
 

We can lock this now