Quote:
|
Originally Posted by #56fanatic
I am not sure how Palmer, Rothlesberger, Eli, Vick, Breese, can even be mentioned. I am not saying these guys wont be better, but to compare year or two stats against a guy that is ranked in the top 10 in most of the all time stats is a bit crazy. Vick is the most over rated, over hyped players in the NFL. Brad Johnson, are you kidding. Serviceable, but not as good. Jake D is not as good as people make him out to be. The guy benefits from throwing hell marrys to Smith. He throws way too many ints and gets help from a pretty damn good defense most of the time. Hasselbeck has had a couple of good years, hasn't played enough yet. Green has been pretty good I'll give you that, McNair, aside from his heart of champion and toughness is one of the great QBs in todays NFL. Drew breese, jury still out. Lets see what he does in New Orleans. Bledsoe has been with 3 teams, 3 offenses to learn and puts up pretty consistant numbers.
Top Qbs in todays NFL (not in any order)
P. Manning
D. McNabb
D. Bledsoe
C. Palmer
S. McNair
K. Warner
J. Plummer
C.Pennington (when healthy)
T. Brady
B. Farve
Rest are probably about average to NFL standards. ( I may have forgotten someone obvious, forgive me if I did)
|
I pretty much agree with you the only thing is that I would have to take out K.Warner to injury prone hasn't finish a season since 2001 and Pennington also 2 injury prone and it appears he's almost out the door.
I would replace them with Culppeper even thought he had a bad year and we still need to see how he'll perform with out Moss but in 2004 he posted MVP number and would ahd won it if Peyton hadn't had that freakish season.
The other player I might add is Hasselbeck he has been a top 10 qb in the past 4 seasons and his number keep getting better each year last year he posted 3459yds with a 24-9 td/int his qb ratign since 2001 has gone from 70.9,87.8,88.8,83.1,98.2 those are great numbers.