SI Ranks Offensive Backfields

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Daseal

Gtripp, what's Orton's win percentage? Answer: Far higher than Campbells.

Josh McDaniels seems to think Orton is better than Campbell too. Neither Orton nor Campbell can hold a candle to Cutler though.

In college, Campbell's win percentage was way higher than Orton's. What's your point? There are clearly other factors at play here, because Campbell, historically, is' the "winner" of the two.

Cutler and Campbell are pretty comparable back here in reality. Orton and Campbell are not. If you actually value win percentage, you should be arguing that Orton is way better than Cutler. I know that's not what your eyes tell you, but dude, he wins.

Also, McDaniels has more to prove than Campbell does, so I'm not sure I'd cite his opinion here yet before he has a chance to prove that he's not crazy.

None of this changes the fact that if you said what you just said to a fanbase that is hard wired into all Kyle Orton dealings, you'd be laughed out of the room as unknowledable. Not unlike McDaniels, who thinks he can win with Orton, AND no defense.