One Last Luck vs RGIII Thread

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by REDSKINS4ever

RG3 vs. Luck is no contest. It's been said that Luck is more pro ready because RG3 had played in the spread offense. Put Luck in the spread and RG3 in a pro offense and what do you got? People would then be saying that RG3 is a better prospect than Luck.

So, to me it's even and therefore no contest. What the other can do in one style of offense, the other can do in another style of offense.

I look at it this way. Luck took a calculus 2 course at Stanford (pro style offense) while RG3 took a Pre-Calculus course (spread-option offense). Both QB's aced their respective courses. Luck had the easier teacher (Pac 10 defenses) but in the end both are very smart. However right now Luck is much more prepared to handle the calculus 3 that is an NFL offense then RG3. At least in terms of learning it.

I still think RG3 will have the better year as he is surrounded by a better team and the AFC South defenses Luck will be facing in division (Titans, Texans, and Jaguars) all ranked in the top 10 last year and that was after adjusting for strength of schedule. NFC East offenses weren't to bad but at the same time they're not great either.

I really think though that Luck vs Griffin is going to be the NFL's version of Bird vs Magin and Gretzky vs Lemieux.