Pocket$ $traight
07-13-2009, 08:51 AM
" As far as being a top 10 QB, I could probably name 15 that I would rather in a playoff game at this point in time. "
Name those 15 my man because I say he is a top 7 QB in the league.
1.Brady
2. Manning
3. Brees
4. Rivers
5. Mcnabb
6. BIG BEN
7. ROMO
8. WARNER
9. E.MANNING
10. CUTLER[/quote]
You are letting regular season stats skew your ratings. I am not talking about a fantasy league, I am talking about a playoff game. Read what you are responding to.
In no particular order...
Brady
P Manning
E Manning
Big Ben
K Warner
J Delhomme
D McNabb
B Favre
P Rivers
C Pennington
J Garcia
Carson Palmer
M Hasselbeck
David Garrard
Drew Brees
Kerry Collins
Joe Flacco
Every one of these guys have proved that they won't throw up all over themselves every time it is a game that counts. All Romo has done is proven that he will find ways to lose. He would probably have a few wins by now if he had just managed a couple of games or held on to a field goal snap.
Chico23231
07-13-2009, 08:51 AM
" As far as being a top 10 QB, I could probably name 15 that I would rather in a playoff game at this point in time. "
Name those 15 my man because I say he is a top 7 QB in the league.
1.Brady
2. Manning
3. Brees
4. Rivers
5. Mcnabb
6. BIG BEN
7. ROMO
8. WARNER
9. E.MANNING
10. CUTLER[/QUOTE]
Id put Superbowl Winners Warner and Eli Manning easily over Romo. Romo and Cutler look better next to one another 9 and 10.
Giantone
07-13-2009, 09:46 AM
"
Name those 15 my man because I say he is a top 7 QB in the league.
1.Brady
2. Manning
3. Brees
4. Rivers
5. Mcnabb
6. BIG BEN
7. ROMO
8. WARNER
9. E.MANNING
10. CUTLER
Id put Superbowl Winners Warner and Eli Manning easily over Romo. Romo and Cutler look better next to one another 9 and 10.[/quote]
Almost same list different order.....................
1.Brady
2. Manning
3. Big Benn
4. Warner
5. Eli
6. McNabb
7.Hasselbeck
8. Brees
9. Rivers
10.Cutler [/quote]
Giantone
07-13-2009, 09:50 AM
What you say is true.
But they still are the top team in playoff history at:
.
No ,not really.NFL has been around along time,count the the teams and game since it started in 1927,not just since the super bowl was formed.:spank:
sandtrapjack
07-13-2009, 10:35 AM
No ,not really.NFL has been around along time,count the the teams and game since it started in 1927,not just since the super bowl was formed.:spank:
Yes and no. By doing that you discount half the league. The NFL did not REALLY come into being until the merger.
saden1
07-13-2009, 11:20 AM
Jacobs done won a super bowl, Romo never won a playoff game. This means Jacobs 1, Romo 0.
Giantone
07-13-2009, 11:59 AM
Yes and no. By doing that you discount half the league.
So , do you mean we start over every time a new team comes in?The NFL has been around since 1927...teams have come and gone but the league started in 1927 and that is when the records started. So ...ahhhhhhh no.
sandtrapjack
07-13-2009, 12:27 PM
So , do you mean we start over every time a new team comes in?The NFL has been around since 1927...teams have come and gone but the league started in 1927 and that is when the records started. So ...ahhhhhhh no.
Don't over think it. By simply recognizing NFL Championships and disregarding AFL Championships, 10 AFL teams are neglected from the discussion.
roth74va
07-13-2009, 12:29 PM
In no particular order...
Brady
P Manning
E Manning
Big Ben
K Warner
J Delhomme
D McNabb
B Favre
P Rivers
C Pennington
J Garcia
Carson Palmer
M Hasselbeck
David Garrard
Drew Brees
Kerry Collins
Joe Flacco
Brady for sure
P Manning for sure
E Manning maybe
Big Ben yes
K Warner yes
J Delhomme maybe
D McNabb yes
B Favre NO.....older version of Romo
P Rivers yes
C Pennington NO.....choker
J Garcia hmmm...maybe
Carson Palmer maybe
M Hasselbeck maybe
David Garrard NO......your reaching now
Drew Brees for sure
Kerry Collins hmmm...maybe
Joe Flacco ROFL...NO...maybe in a year or two
And we are only talking about ONE game, otherwise Romo would have to move higher. I hate Dallas as much as anyone, and I still say Romo is overrated. But when you make the list, he has to make the top 15. Id put him somewhere around 10, but talking heads like to put him up there with Brady/Manning. This whole list might look alot different following the 2009-10 season.
BTW....Aaron Rodgers, Matt Ryan, Matt Cassel, Jay Cutler.
Giantone
07-13-2009, 12:45 PM
Don't over think it. By simply recognizing NFL Championships and disregarding AFL Championships, 10 AFL teams are neglected from the discussion.
Were they in the NFL,no,see not that hard to figure out.We are talking about the NFL,what happen before that team joined the NFL does not matter.