The Legitimacy of Super Bowls 17 & 22

Then we'll counter with the Giants SB 25 win is not legitimate because Scott Norwood shanked a short FG. The Bills should have won and he would have made that kick 9/10 times.

Idiots.

Did they watch SB 22? We dominated the best team in the AFC. If we had to play a few more games that year, we still would have beaten the league.

derrrrrrrrr who cares?

Firstly, I wouldn't have mentioned this topic unless it were true. Giants fans in NYC are quick to say that there are asterisks marked by the Redskins two Super Bowl wins in the 1980s. They are certainly quick to point that out. I've been living in New York City for seven years and when the topic is discussed about great Super Bowl teams, NY Midgets fans are fast to bring that up and they are the only fans to make mention of it. A strike season doesn't matter. When a team wins the Super Bowl and the NFL commissioner hands the organization the trophy, that alone makes it legit. It's similar to a President being sworn into office.

Eli Manning's career isn't over yet. Two Super Bowl MVPs doesn't guarantee that he'll enter the HOF. He has a long ways to go.
Pretty sure they do it to piss you off.Pretty sure I know a few Giant fans also, I'm telling you they don't care.
...........and keep telling yourself that stuff about Eli.

Yeah I agree with Giantone on this, and yes Eli will be a HOFer

derrrrrrrrr who cares?


.......this!

Since the Giants were swept by the Skins last year I dont think their SB win was legit.
(wait....did I just dis the Skins?)

i would point out that their last 3 super bowl victories are illegitimate because they won them by a total combined 8 pts

He's a top 5 QB in the NFL today no doubt

Rogers, Ryan, Brady, RG3, payton

Rogers, Ryan, Brady, RG3, payton


......keep drinking the cool aid.

I wonder if Archie knew his wifes uterus was going to be a quarterback factory.