NC_Skins
12-28-2012, 06:33 PM
Don't downplay vicks impact while in Atlanta, he carried that team for a while and was the most exciting player the league had seen in a while. That being said he's not or was the passer Griff is but a runner he was just as talented as RGIII.
Vick in Atlanta was nothing but a glorified RB. Nothing more, nothing less. Carried the team? Not hardly. That team had good RBs (Dunn) and a decent defense lead by Abraham and Brooking. Let's not act like Vick carried the team. He didn't. If anything, he hindered that team due to him lacking ability at the QB spot.
skinsfaninok
12-28-2012, 06:35 PM
Vick in Atlanta was nothing but a glorified RB. Nothing more, nothing less. Carried the team? Not hardly. That team had good RBs (Dunn) and a decent defense lead by Abraham and Brooking. Let's not act like Vick carried the team. He didn't. If anything, he hindered that team due to his lacking ability at the QB spot.
Idk man I think your being a little hard on the guy, defenses struggled to stop him from having good games. He's not Griffin or was I'm just saying Vick was no bum either. Also his first year in Philly was incredible
The Goat
12-28-2012, 06:39 PM
Why do I still have to read nonsense from those on my ignore list (NCSkins)?
NC_Skins
12-28-2012, 06:41 PM
Why do I still have to read nonsense from those on my ignore list (NCSkins)?
Because I still have to read your idiotic and useless posts.
skinsfaninok
12-28-2012, 06:44 PM
Why do I still have to read nonsense from those on my ignore list (NCSkins)?
What did he say that was nonsense? Lol he's just giving his opinion on it.
The Goat
12-28-2012, 06:52 PM
What did he say that was nonsense? Lol he's just giving his opinion on it.
The comment about Vick in Atlants...just nonsense. He was phenomenal. Could have been better undoubtedly if he actually studied, practiced and worked on his passing game.
I'm all for opinions, such as my (incorrect) one that Shanahan would not have a winning season again. But the past can be fact checked.
skinsfaninok
12-28-2012, 07:06 PM
The comment about Vick in Atlants...just nonsense. He was phenomenal. Could have been better undoubtedly if he actually studied, practiced and worked on his passing game.
I'm all for opinions, such as my (incorrect) one that Shanahan would not have a winning season again. But the past can be fact checked.
I agree about vick, guy was a stud in Atlanta just lazy obviously. And for opinions no doubt we all have some and are right or wrong about them no biggie
Chico23231
12-28-2012, 07:20 PM
The comment about Vick in Atlants...just nonsense. He was phenomenal. Could have been better undoubtedly if he actually studied, practiced and worked on his passing game.
I'm all for opinions, such as my (incorrect) one that Shanahan would not have a winning season again. But the past can be fact checked.
yeah, Vick was a playmaker. first guy ever to get a road win in Green Bay in a playoff game. it was amazing. Vick still way behind as a passer in comparison to RG3.
Just my personal opinion, i dont like an ignore list. People should want to hear opinions no matter how crazy. Plus its funny when NC and Goat fight.
RedskinRat
12-28-2012, 07:24 PM
I agree. How hard is it to ignore something that's posted when you don't agree and can't mount a reasoned counter?
REDSKINS4ever
12-28-2012, 07:35 PM
yeah, Vick was a playmaker. first guy ever to get a road win in Green Bay in a playoff game. it was amazing. Vick still way behind as a passer in comparison to vick.
Just my personal opinion, i dont like an ignore list. People should want to hear opinions no matter how crazy. Plus its funny when NC and Goat fight.
Vick completed a season in which he had a 100.0 passer rating 2 years ago. I'm hoping that his skills aren't starting to erode. He's certainly a player of value playing for a bad team. Once he moves on to his third NFL team, he might start playing better again.