The annual QB carousel

What would you do if you are the Giants GM?

I would trade back with the Raiders get some picks and take Dart at 6 and I would sign Cousins or Winston as a bridge QB.

I would trade back with the Raiders get some picks and take Dart at 6 and I would sign Cousins or Winston as a bridge QB.

It doesn’t matter what Giants do. The gm and coach are dead men walking in 2025 and will be likely unemployed after 25.

Giants might as well trade down and get more picks, as you suggested. If Falcons trade Kirk, he won’t go to the Giants. Giants best bet, rebuild thru the draft. Free agents wanting to win, will avoid the Giants this year. Everyone knows there will be a change next year; so why come to Giants.

It doesn’t matter what Giants do. The gm and coach are dead men walking in 2025 and will be likely unemployed after 25.

Giants might as well trade down and get more picks, as you suggested. If Falcons trade Kirk, he won’t go to the Giants. Giants best bet, rebuild thru the draft. Free agents wanting to win, will avoid the Giants this year. Everyone knows there will be a change next year; so why come to Giants.

Money, I fully understand the outlook on the GM and Coach but any QB that can show some improvement while with the Giants will make out well in the NY Metropolitan area. The Giants lost 8 games by one score and the O line showed a little improvement up until the injuries hit. As always I'll wait and see. IMPO the biggest detractor to the Giants is the NY Press.

Raiders traded a 3rd round pick to Seahawks for Geno Smith.

Raiders traded a 3rd round pick to Seahawks for Geno Smith.


I guess Howell is getting another chance?

I guess Howell is getting another chance?Maybe. Rumor mill indicating they're going after Darnold. Funny thing is McDonald was pumping up Smith so hard recently, so the trade is somewhat surprising.

Could Rodgers go to Vikings and finish the Favre tour? Try to rebound from the Jets disaster and end his career on a better note. JJ can ease back from his injury and learn more. If Rodgers falters again, he can take over.

Could Rodgers go to Vikings and finish the Favre tour? Try to rebound from the Jets disaster and end his career on a better note. JJ can ease back from his injury and learn more. If Rodgers falters again, he can take over.I'm interested in going to Minny if I'm Rodgers. Working with O'Connell, having the best wr in the NFL, and playing in a dome would appeal to me. Flores had the defense rocking too. I could see this going down actually. Division is already stacked.

giants?

I called it in early Feb....just sayin. Giants go with Rodgers.

I called it in early Feb....just sayin. Giants go with Rodgers.

I seriously hope not.