2012 Draft Grades: Post Here

[The Goat]

Originally Posted by FRPLG

He makes a bunch of subjective points. Some may be right or wrong but probably somewhere in between. Then he assigns a quantification to the subjective evaluation. It's both "fair" and totally "idiotic" at the same time because there isn't one single quantifiable thing about it. I'm not knocking Mel any more than any of these other "grades".

Grading a draft is like grading poetry.

That's excellent!

Especially coming from arguably the premier draft analyst, his grade is sort of like saying "This is how well teams listened to me." But regardless it does come down to RGIII for us. If he's an elite QB three years from now this draft gets an A+