Edwards or Rogers/Campbell

[EEich]

Think of it this way. By the time next year's draft rolls around, Campbell will already have a year of NFL experience under his belt and will be that much further along in his development. That year of experience may be more valuable to the Redskins than the possible draft position loss. He'll be developmentally ahead of the QB we might have been forced to draft next year.

[celts32]

Originally Posted by EEich

Think of it this way. By the time next year's draft rolls around, Campbell will already have a year of NFL experience under his belt and will be that much further along in his development. That year of experience may be more valuable to the Redskins than the possible draft position loss. He'll be developmentally ahead of the QB we might have been forced to draft next year.

This is a good way to look at it, but I am still of the belief that we already have our future QB in Ramsey and would have been better served spending that 1st round pick on a weapon to help him as opposed to his eventual replacement.

[EEich]

I think drafting Campbell will make Ramsey a better QB.

[Gmanc711]

I would have rather just taken Carlos Rogers and not had the trade period, if that is an option. I didnt want to trade up to get Edwards (five picks would have been given up just to get him); but I didnt want what happened to play out, I would rather have a first round pick next season.