Predict the top of the draft and bold predictions

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

No way Barkley goes 1. It would be the worst draft move all time

There is no possible way you can say that with a straight face and mean it.

None of these "elite" QBs have separated themselves, Barkley is the number 1 prospect, if I am Cleveland I take Barkley and whichever QB falls to 4, they are guaranteed a QB regardless what they do

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

There is no possible way you can say that with a straight face and mean it.

None of these "elite" QBs have separated themselves, Barkley is the number 1 prospect, if I am Cleveland I take Barkley and whichever QB falls to 4, they are guaranteed a QB regardless what they do

I'm with you on this one. I'd go so far as to take Barkley at 1 and Chubb (if a run on Qbs happen at 2/3) at 4 and use their extra picks to trade up and get Jackson or Rudolph. Browns need good football players. Those 2 guys are best/safest in the draft.

This qb class is weird. A lot of talent but just as many holes and questions.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by sdskinsfan2001

I'm with you on this one. I'd go so far as to take Barkley at 1 and Chubb (if a run on Qbs happen at 2/3) at 4 and use their extra picks to trade up and get Jackson or Rudolph. Browns need good football players. Those 2 guys are best/safest in the draft.

This qb class is weird. A lot of talent but just as many holes and questions.

Exactly, there is no Andrew Luck or John Elway prospect, they are all basically the same guy with a different name. Barkley can help that new QB and for all the crap people say about not drafting a RB until the 7th round or whatever, you notice that all the good teams that don't have Brady or Rodgers have upper level talent at RB, build the OL all you want if your RB sucks your team will still suffer like it did when Zeke went out.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Exactly, there is no Andrew Luck or John Elway prospect, they are all basically the same guy with a different name. Barkley can help that new QB and for all the crap people say about not drafting a RB until the 7th round or whatever, you notice that all the good teams that don't have Brady or Rodgers have upper level talent at RB, build the OL all you want if your RB sucks your team will still suffer like it did when Zeke went out.

In all fairness what has Luck really done? Dude hasn't played a game in well over a yr. It's always impossible damn near to predict a QB's future. Who would have thought Kirk Cousins would be a better / more durable QB than Luck that draft?

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

In all fairness what has Luck really done? Dude hasn't played a game in well over a yr. It's always impossible damn near to predict a QB's future. Who would have thought Kirk Cousins would be a better / more durable QB than Luck that draft?

That is speaking with the benefit of hindsight which is always 20/20, when coming out there was NO question that Luck was going number 1 regardless who else was in that draft with him, here there are literally 4 or 5 possible that can go number 1, so since I have two picks in the top 4 I am guaranteed a QB on the same level as the other 3, so why would I not take the best overall prospect at number 1? That being Barkley, which we have seen rookie RBs take the league by storm over the last few years. That QB now QB now mentality for the sake of passing over the better player ruins teams Justas much as it makes them.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

That is speaking with the benefit of hindsight which is always 20/20, when coming out there was NO question that Luck was going number 1 regardless who else was in that draft with him, here there are literally 4 or 5 possible that can go number 1, so since I have two picks in the top 4 I am guaranteed a QB on the same level as the other 3, so why would I not take the best overall prospect at number 1? That being Barkley, which we have seen rookie RBs take the league by storm over the last few years. That QB now QB now mentality for the sake of passing over the better player ruins teams Justas much as it makes them.

I totally get what you are saying, but the draft class at QB has a lot of different flavors to chose from. Browns need to make a decision at the QB position for the future.

They CANNOT let another Watson or Carson Wentz pass them. They've draft multiple QB after the first round which have failed them tremendously in recent drafts.

If they take Barkley and have Tyrod under center...11 in the box every play, offense does very little and Barkley has a big bruised ego rushing for 650 at a 3.1 avg for the year. The Browns are in the same place again.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

I totally get what you are saying, but the draft class at QB has a lot of different flavors to chose from. Browns need to make a decision at the QB position for the future.

They CANNOT let another Watson or Carson Wentz pass them. They've draft multiple QB after the first round which have failed them tremendously in recent drafts.

If they take Barkley and have Tyrod under center...11 in the box every play, offense does very little and Barkley has a big bruised ego rushing for 650 at a 3.1 avg for the year. The Browns are in the same place again.

You take Lamar Jackson at 12, (traded with Buffalo) you have a future qb, and you run the heck out of RPO for this year. You also have some potential weapons on the WR's, and Taylor can get them the ball enough if the line is stacked.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

I totally get what you are saying, but the draft class at QB has a lot of different flavors to chose from. Browns need to make a decision at the QB position for the future.

They CANNOT let another Watson or Carson Wentz pass them. They've draft multiple QB after the first round which have failed them tremendously in recent drafts.

If they take Barkley and have Tyrod under center...11 in the box every play, offense does very little and Barkley has a big bruised ego rushing for 650 at a 3.1 avg for the year. The Browns are in the same place again.

None of these guys are Wentz or Watson as a prospect, and they still have a choice at #4, they are still guaranteed a QB in the top 4 whether they take him at #1 or #4, so if I am them in that case I am taking the best player at #1 and whichever QB drops to me at #4