Around the league Week 6

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by MTK

Still no clue how the Giants thought RB over QB was the best choice

Seriously ? He wasn't my first choice but he was the right choice ,there isn't a RB like him in next years draft ....and still no proof that last year's class of QB's is any good. I realize it was an ex cowboy who was broadcasting last night so all of you must have turned the sound off but even Ackman said it wasn't Eli . As much as I like Eli and still think he can play he is going to get hurt behind that O line and I don't want to see that , they need to pull him and play the rookie.

[GridIron26]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Seriously ? He wasn't my first choice but he was the right choice ,there isn't a RB like him in next years draft ....and still no proof that last year's class of QB's is any good. I realize it was an ex cowboy who was broadcasting last night so all of you must have turned the sound off but even Ackman said it wasn't Eli . As much as I like Eli and still think he can play he is going to get hurt behind that O line and I don't want to see that , they need to pull him and play the rookie.

I agree with you, so far Barkley looks like a really special player. Giants would have opportunity to build a great offense when they draft a QB next year - a rookie QB with strong supporting cast (Barkley, OBJ, Starling, and Engram). Although they definitely will need to revamp the Oline to protect the rookie QB.

OBJ is awesome player but he talks alot, the new QB will need to have thick skin to manage OBJ.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Seriously ? He wasn't my first choice but he was the right choice ,there isn't a RB like him in next years draft ....and still no proof that last year's class of QB's is any good. I realize it was an ex cowboy who was broadcasting last night so all of you must have turned the sound off but even Ackman said it wasn't Eli . As much as I like Eli and still think he can play he is going to get hurt behind that O line and I don't want to see that , they need to pull him and play the rookie.

Yes seriously. #1 Eli is done, he was done last year. You seem to be in denial over that. #2 the Giants could have had a rookie QB at a bargain price for the next 5 years. Instead they have one of the highest paid RBs and a guy who can’t play at the most important position. But maybe the QB comes next year since it looks like another top 5 pick will be in order.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by MTK

Yes seriously. #1 Eli is done, he was done last year. You seem to be in denial over that. #2 the Giants could have had a rookie QB at a bargain price for the next 5 years. Instead they have one of the highest paid RBs and a guy who can’t play at the most important position. But maybe the QB comes next year since it looks like another top 5 pick will be in order.

MTK we disagree. Barkley was the right pick ,had the Giants picked a QB he would still be on the bench and Eli would still be playing .I have given my thoughts on Eli and no not in denial . My bitch is Odell and it seems the locker room has turned on him not the coach. Is it possible to trade a 95 million dollar cry baby bitch? I keep thinking the Raiders would be stupid enough to take him who in his right mind takes a 95 million dollar contract and just weeks later days he isn't sure if he likes it there??? I would like to see the Giants go after Russel Wilson in Seattle.