Is Carlos Rogers overrated?

[FirstandTen]

Originally Posted by Paintrain

I didn't know that Rogers was 'rated' to be overrated. I put a whole lot more on Walt Harris' shoulders than Rogers. Harris got beat for 2 TD, I only saw Rogers get beat for one deep ball..

Agreed!

[Southpaw]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Paintrain
I didn't know that Rogers was 'rated' to be overrated. I put a whole lot more on Walt Harris' shoulders than Rogers. Harris got beat for 2 TD, I only saw Rogers get beat for one deep ball..

Originally Posted by FirstandTen

Agreed!

Being drafted in the top 10 makes him "rated".

[FirstandTen]

Originally Posted by Southpaw

Quote:
Originally Posted by Paintrain
I didn't know that Rogers was 'rated' to be overrated. I put a whole lot more on Walt Harris' shoulders than Rogers. Harris got beat for 2 TD, I only saw Rogers get beat for one deep ball..



Being drafted in the top 10 makes him "rated".

So is he suppose to be an Pro bowler? I rate him as a rookie playing a tuff positon to jump right into. Like a QB its hard to expect even at top 10 dafted CB to be impact player his rookie year. Time will tell..

[Southpaw]

Originally Posted by FirstandTen

So is he suppose to be an Pro bowler? I rate him as a rookie playing a tuff positon to jump right into. Like a QB its hard to expect even at top 10 dafted CB to be impact player his rookie year. Time will tell..

I personally don't expect anything more of him than you do. I agree, he is a rookie and is going to make mistakes. The problem is, being drafted in the top ten brings along certain expectations from the media and the general public. And if he continues to play like he has thus far, this time next year 90% of the people on this site will be screaming that he is overpaid and overrated. Although his grace period might be a little longer since it was Gibbs that drafted him.

[PSUskinsfan11]

Let's all remember that even though Rogers isn't starting it doesn't mean he isn't progressing. Sean Taylor could have started right away last year with his ability and he still didn't make his first start till the 5th? week vs. the Bears.