Will the Current Treatment of HASKINS Effect His Tenure and Performance with the Redskins?

[SFREDSKIN]

He’s not ready, did you watch the Giants game? On the Golic and Wingo show today, some football scouts and execs say it will probably take a year or 2 for him to be ready. I say leave it to the coaches who see him practice and not some impatient fan/fans who want to see him play.

[Warthog]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

He’s not ready, did you watch the Giants game? On the Golic and Wingo show today, some football scouts and execs say it will probably take a year or 2 for him to be ready. I say leave it to the coaches who see him practice and not some impatient fan/fans who want to see him play.

Haskins had no first team reps the ENTIRE preseason. He has had no reps at all this season. You can’t take a rookie with zero time with the guys he going to play with and throw him into the middle of a game. A FAIR representation of his current talent would be to give him a week to prepare for the Bears team with first team reps and see how he does.

BTW, Peyton MANNING has a 3 INT day his rookie year. Haskins needs experience playing in real games, not watching Case Keenum have 5 turnovers in one game. Or see Colt pass for 119 yds against the Pats. The team is wasting valuable game experience in a horrible season. Why are we the only team to NOT play its rookie QB?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[SFREDSKIN]

Cause he started 10 college games vs 38 games for Daniel Jones in a pro style offense. He’s not ready!! In the old days QB’s sat for 2, 3 years or longer.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Cause he started 10 college games vs 38 games for Daniel Jones in a pro style offense. He’s not ready!! In the old days QB’s sat for 2, 3 years or longer.

13 and Kyler Murray started 14 so that whole he only started 13 games argument is just foolish talk to me. If they cant tailor a gameplan for this kid to play a game against a team that is ACTIVELY TRYING TO LOSE in Miami then why did we draft him?

[BaltimoreSkins]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

13 and Kyler Murray started 14 so that whole he only started 13 games argument is just foolish talk to me. If they cant tailor a gameplan for this kid to play a game against a team that is ACTIVELY TRYING TO LOSE in Miami then why did we draft him?

Word.

[Buffalo Bob]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

13 and Kyler Murray started 14 so that whole he only started 13 games argument is just foolish talk to me. If they cant tailor a gameplan for this kid to play a game against a team that is ACTIVELY TRYING TO LOSE in Miami then why did we draft him?

That is a bad comparison because of Murray's mobility and threat to run, you have to defend Murray much differently than Haskins. Until he gets the mental part of the NFL game down Murray can rely on his athleticism to get by until enough film is gathered on him. Relying on athleticism until the rest of his game develops isn't an option for Haskins.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by Buffalo Bob

That is a bad comparison because of Murray's mobility and threat to run, you have to defend Murray much differently than Haskins. Until he gets the mental part of the NFL game down Murray can rely on his athleticism to get by until enough film is gathered on him. Relying on athleticism until the rest of his game develops isn't an option for Haskins.

50 TDs in a college conference where they actually play defense is nothing to sneeze at. Best way to learn on the job is to actually do the job. It isn't like we have a top flight QB playing ahead of him, we have trash. We are basically parading garbage out there and calling it filet mignon

[Buffalo Bob]

Originally Posted by Buffalo Bob

That is a bad comparison because of Murray's mobility and threat to run, you have to defend Murray much differently than Haskins. Until he gets the mental part of the NFL game down Murray can rely on his athleticism to get by until enough film is gathered on him. Relying on athleticism until the rest of his game develops isn't an option for Haskins.

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

50 TDs in a college conference where they actually play defense is nothing to sneeze at. Best way to learn on the job is to actually do the job. It isn't like we have a top flight QB playing ahead of him, we have trash. We are basically parading garbage out there and calling it filet mignon

No arguing that point, but often a QB's great college stats can be meaningless due to the fact he is playing on a team that usually has a huge talent edge over opponents. Ohio State had 9 total players drafted and 6 of those were on offense. That number was only exceeded by Alabama having 10. How many USC quarterbacks put up great numbers in college only to fail in the NFL?

The numbers a player puts up in college do not dictate readiness to play in the NFL. Haskins poor footwork and needing work on protecting himself better doesn't need to be done while risking his confidence and health.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

He’s not ready, did you watch the Giants game? On the Golic and Wingo show today, some football scouts and execs say it will probably take a year or 2 for him to be ready. I say leave it to the coaches who see him practice and not some impatient fan/fans who want to see him play.

I do believe that you can give him 30- 40 plays and go with that. You can go w/ plays he ran at Ohio State. He ain't ready for the full play book but you can gameplan for plays he's comfortable with. If he struggles then put in the Case or Colt.

Haskins is most likely going to fail here anyway. It's just not a place for a young QB to be successful in. A new coach is going to come in and be forced to work w/ him. That is how dysfunction starts, a la RG3 and Jay. A new coach most likely will want to bring in his own guy, play his own guy.