American Idol Final 2

[Schneed10]

Originally Posted by dmek25

i think the whole thing is fixed.im not getting the taylor thing.as far as im concerned,he has no talent and dances like a retard.mcphee has minimum talent but has the look they are after.and besides that,no way that vote was that close.its almost turning into the wwe,television entertainment

Explain why the vote couldn't have been that close. I don't see the logic there.

All three are very similar in talent level, in my estimation. I can easily see why they ended up in a close vote. Can you honestly say that one is head and shoulders better than the other two?? If so, why?