My Last Post Ever.

[illdefined]

Originally Posted by Sheriff Gonna Getcha

I started the props to Brunell thread last week and I stand by it - he played well and deserved to praise. This week, Brunell played horribly and deserves ridicule.

I am tired of people who see things in black/white and right/wrong terms. It's not "all or nothing." There should be room for nuance in an intelligent debate.

Perhaps some are not capable of recognizing that it is totally legitimate to praise Brunell one week and bash him the next. He plays inconsistently and therefore gets praised/bashed on an inconsistent basis.

aw yes, the infamous Poll that had him play either Sub-Par or 'Great'.

and its not legitmate to bash the PLAYER one week and not the next. you can bash/praise his PERFORMANCE as the weeks go, but the player himself people can make a judgement on and 'inconsistent' has always been a euphemism for BAD in this league.

[Sheriff Gonna Getcha]

Originally Posted by illdefined

aw yes, the infamous Poll that had him play either Sub-Par or 'Great'.

and its not legitmate to bash the PLAYER one week and not the next. you can bash/praise his PERFORMANCE as the weeks go, but the player himself people can make a judgement on and 'inconsistent' has always been a euphemism for BAD in this league.

I've been bashing Brunell for quite some time. I've said for a long time that he can't throw over the middle, isn't all that accurate, and is too conservative. The only point of last week's thread was to give a player who deserved a lot of blame for this season's outcome so praise for playing well. I simply don't see any inconsistency in that.