All NOT in favor of Portis deal!

Sheriff Gonna Getcha · 02-24-2004, 09:13 PM

I'm still in favor of the signing.

1. We're gonna pay top dollar to keep Bailey (if we don't trade him)
2. We need to consummate a deal soon to stay well beneath the cap for FA
3. I'm not so sure the Lions would give their 1st pick + another pick
4. Portis will demand a LOT less than Bailey (probably 5 million/yr. not 9 mill)
5. The 6th overall pick is going to cost a boatload to sign
6. If you trade down from #6, you're going to pay a boatload for 2 high picks
7. The draft can be risky (see Desmond Howard et al)
8. Gibbs' system requires a top notch, proven back
9. Top notch proven backs don't come cheap (unless they're old)
10. Portis is, IMHO, the best back in the league and is one of the youngest
11. Signing Kearse, Springs, & Gardener/Washington will offset Champ's loss

View Poll Results: Champ and our 2nd rounder to Denver for Portis, your thoughts?
Great move!	31	59.62%
Bad move!	6	11.54%
I'm not sure	15	28.85%
Voters: 52. You may not vote on this poll

02-24-2004, 09:13 PM	#11
Sheriff Gonna Getcha Franchise Player Join Date: Feb 2004 Age: 46 Posts: 8,317	I'm still in favor of the signing. 1. We're gonna pay top dollar to keep Bailey (if we don't trade him) 2. We need to consummate a deal soon to stay well beneath the cap for FA 3. I'm not so sure the Lions would give their 1st pick + another pick 4. Portis will demand a LOT less than Bailey (probably 5 million/yr. not 9 mill) 5. The 6th overall pick is going to cost a boatload to sign 6. If you trade down from #6, you're going to pay a boatload for 2 high picks 7. The draft can be risky (see Desmond Howard et al) 8. Gibbs' system requires a top notch, proven back 9. Top notch proven backs don't come cheap (unless they're old) 10. Portis is, IMHO, the best back in the league and is one of the youngest 11. Signing Kearse, Springs, & Gardener/Washington will offset Champ's loss

All NOT in favor of Portis deal!

Locker Room Main Forum