Santana vs. Randy

[12thMan]

Wow, I think we all ate a little crow in hindsight.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

Wow, I think we all ate a little crow in hindsight.

What happens is people tend to judge things with the burgundy and gold glasses on around here. I mean this whole thread was just silly. R. Moss has over 100 TD's!!!!! R. Moss is a better WR period. Always has been and always will be.

[12thMan]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

What happens is people tend to judge things with the burgundy and gold glasses on around here. I mean this whole thread was just silly. R. Moss has over 100 TD's!!!!! R. Moss is a better WR period. Always has been and always will be.

Just to be fair, I'm sure people were judging results soley on the previous three seasons, not the entire body of work.

No one here is disputing whether or not Santana has had a better career than Randy.

[Twilbert07]

I sure would like to have Randy this year.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

Just to be fair, I'm sure people were judging results soley on the previous three seasons, not the entire body of work.

No one here is disputing whether or not Santana has had a better career than Randy.

I see your point but Oak had the worst QB situation in the NFL. I was not going to judge R. Moss with Walter and Brooks throwing him the ball behind a terrible o-line. Plus they had some guy who was running a bed and breakfast who hadn't coached since 91 running the offense. No WR would have done well on that team.

R. Moss is not a leader. I don't think he does well in a situation where he has to carry the team like he was asked to do in Oak. But when he has solid vets and supporting cast around him he is going to thrive and right now he is in a perfect situation.