Dallas Sartz Signs with Vikings

[freddyg12]

Originally Posted by DGreene28

I pretty familiar with the history of the NFL draft... How many of the Giants picks in the 2007 draft do you think had a major impact in the playoffs and Super Bowl? How about 5th round and later?

RoundPick (Overall)PlayerPositionSchool
120 (20)Aaron RossCBTexas
219 (51)Steve SmithWRUSC
317 (81)Jay AlfordDTPenn State
417 (116)Zak DeOssieOLBBrown
516 (153)Kevin BossTEWestern Oregon
615 (189)Adam KoetsTOregon State
714 (224)Michael JohnsonSArizona
7*40 (250)Ahmad BradshawRBMarshall* - Compensatory pick

Again, these guys are hardly "impact players" IMO. If you mean good "role players" then you've made a good point.

The point of my post isn't refuted by yours; you said previously that our 5th round pick "can't even make the team" as if that's indicative of poor scouting. My point in return is that a high no. of 5th round picks don't make teams, and that's on good & bad teams. For the few low round picks that contributed on the Giants squad, I'm sure there are some 5th & 6th round picks at home that didn't make the team.