Colt Brennan

[charlielyons]

Originally Posted by Slingin Sammy 33

Matt Ryan and Flacco were picked in the first 20 picks of the draft. Colt Brennan was a 6th rounder. He's a typical Hawaii / June Jones "system" guy, that played against inferior talent in college. Put him at QB and we'd be 2-11 rather than 7-6. Colt Brennan = Timmy Chang.

chris cooley played in that same conference and is producing and he was a 3rd rd pick

[Slingin Sammy 33]

Originally Posted by charlielyons

chris cooley played in that same conference and is producing and he was a 3rd rd pick

so what's your point?

[charlielyons]

Originally Posted by Slingin Sammy 33

so what's your point?

whats my point, my point is just because hes not a first round pick and from the WAC , doesnt mean brennan wont produce......cooley played for utah state which is in the WAC and was a 3rd round pick...

[Slingin Sammy 33]

Originally Posted by charlielyons

whats my point, my point is just because hes not a first round pick and from the WAC , doesnt mean brennan wont produce......cooley played for utah state which is in the WAC and was a 3rd round pick...

See post # 35...thanks BD.

I didn't say he wouldn't produce because he's not a 1st round pick, or because he's from the WAC. I say he won't produce because: He's a system guy from Hawaii, he doesn't have a strong arm, he isn't physically gifted, he has a poor throwing motion / release. He doesn't strike me as a real good decision maker.

The facts on him "are what they are". He's not a first round level talent. The WAC is an inferior conference to the SEC, ACC, Big 12, Big 10, PAC 10. Timmy Chang put up similar numbers to Colt in his time at Hawaii. Timmy Chang is now in the CFL.

When Colt actually wins an NFL game as a starter, then we can open the discussion on whether he'll amount to more than a career back-up. Right now if JC goes down (God forbid), I'm glad we would go to Collins rather than Brennan.

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by Slingin Sammy 33

See post # 35...thanks BD.

I didn't say he wouldn't produce because he's not a 1st round pick, or because he's from the WAC. I say he won't produce because: He's a system guy from Hawaii, he doesn't have a strong arm, he isn't physically gifted, he has a poor throwing motion / release. He doesn't strike me as a real good decision maker.

The facts on him "are what they are". He's not a first round level talent. The WAC is an inferior conference to the SEC, ACC, Big 12, Big 10, PAC 10. Timmy Chang put up similar numbers to Colt in his time at Hawaii. Timmy Chang is now in the CFL.

When Colt actually wins an NFL game as a starter, then we can open the discussion on whether he'll amount to more than a career back-up. Right now if JC goes down (God forbid), I'm glad we would go to Collins rather than Brennan.

Thank you. All these people who think Colt Brennan could step in and be viable NFL QB right now are giving me a headache. I like that we drafted him, and I like the thought of developing him over time. It's frustrating as hell to lose, but benching Campbell is just dumb.

Although the conference you played in in college doesn't matter all that much. Joe Flacco played for Delaware for god's sake. Romo? Eastern Michigan. McNair played at Alcorn State... There are plenty of damn good NFL players that didn't play in BCS conferences.