For all you D Hall lovers

[SouperMeister]

Originally Posted by celts32

I would love to have them both...but if the redskins are making a choice to only give one of them a long term deal then I think it should be Rogers following next season. I also do not think Hall is worth the kind of deal that is being rumored. He does not deserve to be paid as one of the top CB's in the league after the season he had last year.

One thing to consider is age. Hall is only 25 and Rogers is 27. Rogers is probably better in man coverage, but with his stone hands, he almost never makes plays when they present themselves. Hall has demonstrated the ability to make a big INT. I'd love to keep both, but given the choice, I believe that I'd take Hall.