Per Vinny Cerrato, JC is our QB this season!

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by BigHairedAristocrat

I dont know what factual evidence i can provide that i havent already. I dont use circular logic. I have an opinion, based on facts. You have an opinion, also based on facts. Which facts we chose to use to support our arguments reinforces our existing beliefs. You reject the arguments I make, exaggerate my position to the extreme to make it look foolish and ive taken similar approaches myself.

I would like nothing more than to be wrong about Campbell, because it would mean:

1) Cerrato and Snyder knew what they were doing when they paired the Square peg and round hole... therefore the franchise is in more capeable hands than we thought.

2) We wont need to go shopping for a QB in 2010 when the market will be thin and we'll be crammed for cap space (Roger Godell thinks the CBA will be extended before 2010).

3) We can probably afford to trade Brennan for picks in 2011.

4) We'll have some freakin' stability at the position for the first time since i cant even remember.

5) Zorn will stay, meaning we wont need to continue the constant merry-go-round coaching turnover that happens every few years... the entire franchise can be stable again.

And all that would be nice... but im just not drinkin the koolaid.

I've never asked you to slurp the Kool-Aid, dude. Just to try to see what you're doing in perspective. My goal certainly wasn't to make you look foolish, but I think that's been a byproduct of the back and forth we've had.

In reality:

1) Jay Cutler isn't getting traded (the reasons for this are economic in principle, not cap-wise, but like bargaining wise) even though the trade rumors will continue throughout the offseason.
2) Jay Cutler will likely have continued success in the Denver offense
3) Jason Campbell will continue to improve here, just as the offense around him does
4) We'll look back on this thread hilariously in a year, and realize that this debate was a waste of time. Unless the search function breaks, then we'll never see this again.
5) Zorn probably will stay through 2010 at least.

It's somewhat demeaning that you still want to think there were facts used to back your position, and that the trade proposal wasn't totally ludicrous, but don't you worry, I'll get over it.