Braylon Edwards trade talk

[gibbsisgod]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Kurt Warner has a superbowl ring,the injury against the jets wasn't lost on me.yet there is something about him ....the give me a new contract or trade me thing and lets not forget that the #2 man should be open and making playes when the #1 man is double and triple coverd...alll the time, and this was with out a running game to speak of.You say one outburst ....only one caught on TV from what people say at least 5 during the season and that includes during training camp.TO ME and this is my opinion only we have young talent that can play just as well given the chance.

Like Who? Manningham? He got injured early and was never a fatcor. Moss? You guys don't dress him on gamedays even when he is healthy(which hasn't been often). He made it on the field last season some in garbage time and put up some nice numbers but it was just that, garbage time. I do like Smith but he is nowhere close to AB. You WRs are a joke and if you don't do something about it, its not going to be pretty.

And yes, I know the Redskins WRs are not worldbeaters but comparing the your guys to AB is a joke.

[gibbsisgod]

Question Giantone:
What do you want the Giants to do? Go through the draft for a WR or trade for someone? If you want to go the draft route, who do you like?

[skins89moss]

Why do Redskins fans give a sh*t what the Giants do with their draft picks unless our team is going to benefit. We better worry about what the heck our Front Office Ex. are going to do on Draft day.

[gibbsisgod]

Originally Posted by skins89moss

Why do Redskins fans give a sh*t what the Giants do with their draft picks unless our team is going to benefit. We better worry about what the heck our Front Office Ex. are going to do on Draft day.

Are you asking me? I just want to know what Giantone thinks.

[AuburnRedskin]

Not unless Edwards suddenly learns to catch again. The Redskins already have enough WRs with that problem.

Sorry for the venom, but Braylon was my fantasy bust this past year and cost me the title.

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by Zerohero

Just for the sake of argument Santana is our burner, so Boldin fits in perfectly with us. Again im not talking about giving picks, strictly as a player who could fit into the system.

Yup, you are right. But talk earlier in the thread concerned whether Boldin was a true #1. And notice that, if your argument is correct, this means we can't trade Moss for Boldin as some suggested.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by gibbsisgod

Question Giantone:
What do you want the Giants to do? Go through the draft for a WR or trade for someone? If you want to go the draft route, who do you like?

Personally I want them to draft a youngster and go that rout.I like the kid from NC... Hackeem Nicks I think his name is ,good speed ,good hands and a vertical leap that can rivel LaBron's(joke )..........You are right about our youngsters but remember they didn't get on the field becuase of Plax and Toomer both are gone and two must step up and we also have Tyre...who is more special teams but can also play WR.I also would not be sad if they got the big TE to help Boss ...Petegrew (sp)I think his name is.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by skins89moss

Why do Redskins fans give a sh*t what the Giants do with their draft picks unless our team is going to benefit. We better worry about what the heck our Front Office Ex. are going to do on Draft day.

Becuase it's normal to be interested in you divison opponents and what they are up to.Except for a few Exstreme skin rejects() ......I would say 99.9 % of eveyone here has a good clasp of football knowledge.Remember what you guys do could affect what we do,just food for thought.

[WaldSkins]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Personally I want them to draft a youngster and go that rout.I like the kid from NC...Nix I think his name is ,good speed ,good hands and a vertical leap that can rivel LaBron's(joke )..........You are right about our youngsters but remember they didn't get on the field becuase of Plax and Toomer both are gone and two must step up and we also have Tyre...who is more special teams but can also play WR.I also would not be sad if they got the big TE to help Boss ...Petegrew (sp)I think his name is.

Hackeem Nicks-#88-WR

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Kurt Warner has a superbowl ring,the injury against the jets wasn't lost on me.yet there is something about him ....the give me a new contract or trade me thing and lets not forget that the #2 man should be open and making playes when the #1 man is double and triple coverd...alll the time, and this was with out a running game to speak of.You say one outburst ....only one caught on TV from what people say at least 5 during the season and that includes during training camp.TO ME and this is my opinion only we have young talent that can play just as well given the chance.

Gibbsisgod is right. Giantone, you guys are not looking pretty at WR without Plax, development of the younger ones or not.

Nicks looks like a good prospect but if you think that Boldin is slow...Nicks is not gonna be the field stretcher than you guys need.

You guys had better find a speedy WR upgrade or defenses next year will be inching towards the line and taking away those holes that Jacobs has enjoyed. Without a speedster your passing game AND running game will take hits.

[Stuck in TX]

Boldin + a little speedy guy will be okay IMO. Edwards is (still) a project in the works and has yet to prove a thing. Boldin could serve as a possession receiver and Moss's bro, Manningham, etc... could serve as a slightly speedier slot option. All the Giants would then need is an outside guy to bomb it out to... Either way, we will have them dialed down pretty well with our secondary ;-)

[SBXVII]

I think the players that alway intrigue me is the kids of previous players or coach's. ie; Robiskie. They had him on the NFL network talking with him and he seems like a good guy and probably decent player. Said he had decent hands.

I see Aaron Kelly from Clemson and wonder if he's related to our Kelly. lol. perhaps younger brother? most likely not. Funny if we picked him up in late round and had 2 Kelly's on the team.

Greg Orton from Purdue. Any relation to Kyle Orton?

You all get my point. Do any of you know of any other players who have siblings coming out in this yrs draft like Dockery? or kids like Robiskie?

[SBXVII]

Also theres a

Dominick Goodman from Cincinnati

and a

Dominiko Goodman from Georgia

are they brothers? both WR's expected to not be drafted.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by WaldSkins

Hackeem Nicks-#88-WR

Thank You.........

[skins89moss]

Originally Posted by Giantone

Thank You.........

Well the Giants do have some young WR , not to mention David Tyree who did not play all year. Was he just a Super Bowl 1 catch wonder? Well the Giants I dont like any othe NFC East teams but i do respect how they play defense. They served us our lunch twice and the second time they didnt have Plax Burress. That game our defense looked over match just like our offense. I still believe the G-Men and Eagles are the teams to worry about in the NFC East for us. Dallas lost T.Owens and that will hurt their offense this year. G-Men why take B. Edwards when you can get A.Bouldon.