Piggyback thread-Who is your NFC East starting lineup?

Originally Posted by dmek25

QB- as much as i hate to say it, Manning( the only one with a ring)
WR- Moss and the gang. not even close
PR/KR- ill take the skins. Cartwright and Desean Jackson are a wash. and Randle- El still has some left in the tank

Interesting picks. Eli puzzles me. I dont understand how people see a ring and think hes better than guys like McNabb or Romo. The Skins WRs arent a bad pick but I find it odd you said it isnt even close.

As for PR/KR this one really has me perplexed. I dont see Cartwright and Jackson being a wash. The main part of your lineup that throws me off is saying Randle El still has some in the tank. If he still has some in the tank why has he been running on empty for years?

The rest of your lineup makes sense to me but those things I listed above has me scratching my head. Overall though its a very solid lineup.

[pick-ups]

Originally Posted by Brian Orakpo

Interesting picks. Eli puzzles me. I dont understand how people see a ring and think hes better than guys like McNabb or Romo. The Skins WRs arent a bad pick but I find it odd you said it isnt even close.

As for PR/KR this one really has me perplexed. I dont see Cartwright and Jackson being a wash. The main part of your lineup that throws me off is saying Randle El still has some in the tank. If he still has some in the tank why has he been running on empty for years?

The rest of your lineup makes sense to me but those things I listed above has me scratching my head. Overall though its a very solid lineup.

Everyone has their opinions.

Originally Posted by pick-ups

Everyone has their opinions.

Yeah and I understand that. Im just giving feedback on his lineup. I liked it overall but those different ones perplexed me a little. I just wanted to know more about his reasoning behind those picks.

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Cowboys Quarterbacks, Cowboys Running Backs, Eagles Receivers, Cowboys Tight Ends, Eagles Offensive Line, Giants Defensive Line, Redskins Linebackers, Redskins Defensive Backs, Cowboys Specialists, Eagles Coaching Staff

Damn dude we pretty much had the same lineup. The only ones we had different were the QB and LB position. I guess great minds think alike.