smoot vs harris/wilds

[Kevikazi]

Did Smoot forget how Torry Holt lit him up during Pre-Season? And, how Keyshawn Johnson caught every ball thrown his way when Smoot was covering him? He is a good corner against opponent's #2 receiver but he is not a starting corner material...and doesn't deserve to be paid like a top 10 cornerback.

[Indyskin]

Originally Posted by Kevikazi

Did Smoot forget how Torry Holt lit him up during Pre-Season? And, how Keyshawn Johnson caught every ball thrown his way when Smoot was covering him? He is a good corner against opponent's #2 receiver but he is not a starting corner material...and doesn't deserve to be paid like a top 10 cornerback.

....with you and I have always thought this. Walt Harris' coverage skills are equal to Smoots, if not better. IMO, I would rather have Harris playing in front of Smoot in all situations because of the physical play he brings, plus he can tackle. Smoot doesn't tackle.