Kurt Warner announces retirement after 12 seasons

[Swarley]

If you're going to make that assumption you must also ask this question. Did Manning benefit more from having all those receivers or did all those receivers benefit from having Manning at QB? My guess is that it's a fair bit of both so it's really a non point. No QB will be succesful without good teammates. Brady didnt have elite WR's for years but he always had a great O-line that kept him upright for the most part. The ideal situation is to have a good QB with good weapons because every QB falls off to a certain extent without them.