Redskins among draft winners

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by Longtimefan

Was good to see the writer actually included McNabb, Jarmon and Carriker as a part of the draft class. Some post-draft evaluators chose (for whatever reasons) to omit the three as if they shouldn't be included.

So do you count Jarmon twice? Last year and this year?

[Longtimefan]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

So do you count Jarmon twice? Last year and this year?

I would think he should be included in the 2010 draft class though he came to us prematurely in the supplemental draft. Technically, he was our third round pick in this years's draft. How do you characterize it Smoot, in your opinion should he be considered as this year's pick, or 2009?

[JLee9718]

Didn't Oakland have a pretty good draft? We could've gotten Campbell, the offensive lineman out of Maryland, too. That would've made our draft even better. When the Redskins didn't select him, Oakland did with the following pick.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by Longtimefan

I would think he should be included in the 2010 draft class though he came to us prematurely in the supplemental draft. Technically, he was our third round pick in this years's draft. How do you characterize it Smoot, in your opinion should he be considered as this year's pick, or 2009?

I don't know. I mean we technically drafted (albeit supplementarily) last year. So I think it would count for last year? But then you can also make the argument that it would count for this year too. I honestly don't know the answer

[Rainy Parade]

well, this year's 3rd was surrendered for Jarmon (same for Mcnabb/2nd).

so if the analysts downgrade us for not having picks they should acknowledge where they went.
now, if we were still missing a 2010 from an old brandon lloyd pick, then shame on us.