Hakeem Nicks will miss Redskins game (Leg Injury)

[SirClintonPortis]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

I thought he would be a superstar out of Mich, he's solid but no Nicks

Even so, would you start him over Moss or Armstrong on this team? I would be tempted to.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by SirClintonPortis

Even so, would you start him over Moss or Armstrong on this team? I would be tempted to.

Nah, Manningham is a third receiver on this team and is a little too Devin Thomas-y for my tastes. His gaffes are usually spectacular.

I think he has more football ability than DT ever would, but for the same reason I think giving up on Thomas was justifiable, I think Manningham is closer to the end in the pros than many think. I think the Giants want to replace him, and just haven't found anyone capable enough, especially with Steve Smith out.