Is anyone else just absolutely disgusted with DM5's play?

[diehard]

We, the knowledgeable fans, knew what McNabb brought to the table.

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by diehard

We, the knowledgeable fans, knew what McNabb brought to the table.

I'm pretty sure a couple of Philly fans have seen comments similar to the ones in the opening post around our fanbase and can't help but laugh. In fact I saw a lot of Philly fans predicting that we would eventually feel this way. I just personally thought it wouldn't be this soon.

The question we need to answer now is weather DM5 is a Kurt Warner or a Daunte Culpepper/Matt Hasselbeck. Obviously I'd hate to let Donovan go to another team and pull a B Lloyd on us especially since McNabb doesn't even come close to the amount of a luggage that a guy like Lloyd came with. However it would suck to hold onto him only to find out that he's done.

[freddyg12]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag359

I'm pretty sure a couple of Philly fans have seen comments similar to the ones in the opening post around our fanbase and can't help but laugh. In fact I saw a lot of Philly fans predicting that we would eventually feel this way. I just personally thought it wouldn't be this soon.

The question we need to answer now is weather DM5 is a Kurt Warner or a Daunte Culpepper/Matt Hasselbeck. Obviously I'd hate to let Donovan go to another team and pull a B Lloyd on us especially since McNabb doesn't even come close to the amount of a luggage that a guy like Lloyd came with. However it would suck to hold onto him only to find out that he's done.

Nice question, Dirt. Warner came back w/the Cards & played at a pro bowl level after he looked totally done w/the g-men. I think McNabb has it in him. I know he's looked bad at times, but he's also shown more leadership & playmaking ability than JC.

Has anyone considered that McNabb has been mentally exhausted by this season too? The whole team looked bad sunday, the collective psyche of the team seems tired. I'm not making excuses, but there were/are a lot of transitions being undertaken this year. I think McNabb & Shan/Allen deserve another year before we start to reconsider what they've started.