If Pryor entered the supplemental draft would you pick him.

[NC_Skins]

So you'd give up a probable starter (4th: Roy Helu (RB) Nebraska) for a QB who'll never be a successful QB in the NFL? Vinny? Is that you?




When will you people get it out of your heads. The following QBs do not translate well to the NFL.

Tyrelle Pryor
Pat White
Antwaan Randle El
Marcus Vick
Tyrod Taylor
Eric Crouch
Armanti Edwards
Cam Newton
Scott Frost


Two that are still debatable...Vince Young and Mike Vick too. Beyond this past year, Vick hasn't done diddly squat as a QB. I'll need to see some consecutive years of serious production at the QB stats (not running) to change my mind.


Sure these guys were awesome QBs and played well at their level, but this isn't college.

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by NC_Skins

So you'd give up a probable starter (4th: Roy Helu (RB) Nebraska) for a QB who'll never be a successful QB in the NFL? Vinny? Is that you?




When will you people get it out of your heads. The following QBs do not translate well to the NFL.

Tyrelle Pryor
Pat White
Antwaan Randle El
Marcus Vick
Tyrod Taylor
Eric Crouch
Armanti Edwards
Cam Newton
Scott Frost


Two that are still debatable...Vince Young and Mike Vick too. Beyond this past year, Vick hasn't done diddly squat as a QB. I'll need to see some consecutive years of serious production at the QB stats (not running) to change my mind.


Sure these guys were awesome QBs and played well at their level, but this isn't college.

Yes but unlike a lot of the QB's you listed Pryor has been successful in a pro style offense. Also Cam Newton and Tyrod Taylor haven't even taken a snap in the NFL.

[NC_Skins]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag59

Yes but unlike a lot of the QB's you listed Pryor has been successful in a pro style offense.

Oh, you mean like this guy?

Troy Smith - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


I think we've seen how that all works out. I'd dare say they were pretty much identical players.

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by NC_Skins

Oh, you mean like this guy?

Troy Smith - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


I think we've seen how that all works out. I'd dare say they were pretty much identical players.

Yes but Troy Smith didn't have a first or second round grade. Scouts knew he was going to be a late round pick. The only time he was mentioned in the first round was when people who only watch college football, and in turn have little idea what pro scouts look for, started suggesting that he should be a first round pick shortly after he won the Heisman.

Pryor even with his average production has been projected as a first round pick for the last two years.

And the funny thing is I'm not even that sure of him, but he's certainly a more promising pro then Troy Smith. Still I think it was unfair that you cast Newton aside before he even took an NFL snap. Appologize to Newton and his family. Not Taylor though, he's to short, short people suck.

[NC_Skins]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag59

Pryor even with his average production has been projected as a first round pick for the last two years.

LOL. WHAT? I've never heard of Pryor being remotely discussed as such. Links? I assure you, if he were projected that high, he would have came out this year after playing the bowl game.

Originally Posted by Dirtbag59

Appologize to Newton and his family. Not Taylor though, he's to short, short people suck.

Sure, but it'll cost them. I'd say his "fee" to play for Auburn will cover it.

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by NC_Skins

LOL. WHAT? I've never heard of Pryor being remotely discussed as such. Links? I assure you, if he were projected that high, he would have came out this year after playing the bowl game.

Don't you remember? Last year before we traded for McNabb the 2011 class was suppose to be great because then we could possibly get Locker, Pryor, Luck, or Mallet. Those were the four guys. Walter Football also listed Pryor as a First Round pick and USA Today listed him among the top juniors that could declare for the next draft in 2010 along with Andrew Luck.

Edit: Never mind you got here in Late '10.