Around The NFL - Divisional Round

[44Deezel]

Originally Posted by NC_Skins

Absolutely no way. Again, let's look at the defenses. Having a top 5 defense compared to having a bottom 5 defense. It's not even REMOTELY in the same ball park.

Again. The cold hard facts that the Patriots go 11-5 WITHOUT Brady solidifies my argument and pretty much makes yours invalid. The fact the Colts go from a 10-6 playoff team to the #1 draft pick in the NFL also backs up that case.


Hey guys, I guess Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson are better QBs than Dan Marino!!! That's pretty much the type of argument you are using.

Yeah, but they went 18-1 the year before with Brady, and he set the single season record for TDs with 50 (breaking Manning's record). If it weren't for mind boggling drops by Brady's receivers, Manning wouldn't even have a ring. He put his team ahead with 2 minutes to go against the Giants in the Super Bowl, and it took one of the biggest circus plays of all time for the Giants to win that game. Brady is clutch while Manning spends 30 seconds each play trying to figure out how he's going to outsmart the Defense, which in the playoffs, has backfired for him. One of his teammates who was not an idiot Kicker even said so.

Brady = Montana
Manning = Marino

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by 44Deezel

Yeah, but they went 18-1 the year before with Brady, and he set the single season record for TDs with 50 (breaking Manning's record). If it weren't for mind boggling drops by Brady's receivers, Manning wouldn't even have a ring. He put his team ahead with 2 minutes to go against the Giants in the Super Bowl, and it took one of the biggest circus plays of all time for the Giants to win that game. Brady is clutch while Manning spends 30 seconds each play trying to figure out how he's going to outsmart the Defense, which in the playoffs, has backfired for him. One of his teammates who was not an idiot Kicker even said so.

Brady = Montana
Manning = Marino

Didn't Brady have Moss for those 50 TDs where Moss caught 23 of them? Both are great but I gotta put Manning ahead by a smige.

[44Deezel]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Didn't Brady have Moss for those 50 TDs where Moss caught 23 of them? Both are great but I gotta put Manning ahead by a smige.

Fair enough, but 36 TDs and only 4TDs without Moss.

Plus, Moss must have not been that good because New England only gave up a 4th round pick to get him.

If Welker is all world because he warranted a 2nd round pick than Moss must not be all that because they only traded a 4th to get him.

Just assuming you're consistent with your logic

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by 44Deezel

Fair enough, but 36 TDs and only 4TDs without Moss.

Plus, Moss must have not been that good because New England only gave up a 4th round pick to get him.

If Welker is all world because he warranted a 2nd round pick than Moss must not be all that because they only traded a 4th to get him.

Just assuming you're consistent with your logic

Now we all know that might be the biggest steal of all time. The Raiders gave up on him and he wanted out. People thought he was finished.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Now we all know that might be the biggest steal of all time. The Raiders gave up on him and he wanted out. People thought he was finished.

The Haynesworth trade could have easily been the same thing. Alas, the big guy might actually be finished, at least as a down to down, week to week NFL player.

[NC_Skins]

Originally Posted by 44Deezel

Yeah, but they went 18-1 the year before with Brady, and he set the single season record for TDs with 50 (breaking Manning's record). If it weren't for mind boggling drops by Brady's receivers, Manning wouldn't even have a ring. He put his team ahead with 2 minutes to go against the Giants in the Super Bowl, and it took one of the biggest circus plays of all time for the Giants to win that game. Brady is clutch while Manning spends 30 seconds each play trying to figure out how he's going to outsmart the Defense, which in the playoffs, has backfired for him. One of his teammates who was not an idiot Kicker even said so.

You do realize the year that Manning broke the TD record they actually pulled him in games. They weren't trying to get the record unlike Belicheck and Brady who stayed into the 4th quarter up by 30 and still throwing bombs. Our game in New England should prove my point.

That's the only way he breaks Manning's record, and the most important game of the season and where were those TDs and offense? Nowhere to be found. Choked. The great Tom Brady choked.


Tell me who this player that called out Peyton is. Backfired? Have you seen the numbers that Peyton has accumulated? Looks like it backfired.

Some of you Brady nut huggers are incredible. You refuse to acknowledge that Tom was (still is) on a better team, yet claim that Manning had all the talent even though it's shown that same talent did nothing before or after him. DERP.

I'm done with this.