SI's Top 10 QB's Under age 25

[Rexi]

SI.com - Photo Gallery - Ranking Top 10 Young QBs: <br> 25 and Under

I think the list is horrible. I mean Aaron "Tedford Bust Waiting to Happen" Rodgers is #7, why? Explain that one to me. I have no idea how you can argue that Young, Gradkowski, and Rodgers are better than A. Smith, he should be no lower that 7th on the list IMO.

My top 10:

1. Roethlisberger
2. Rivers
3. E.Manning
4. Schaub
5. A.Smith
6. Leinart
7. Cutler
8. Gradkowski
9. V.Young
10. A. Rodgers

What does everyone else think?

[steveo395]

That list is pretty retarded. Jay Cutler hasn't taken a snap yet, Aaron Rodgers has barely played, Vince Young has been pretty crappy so far. Isn't this supposed to be a list of the top QBs 25 and under? This shouldn't be based on potential. I'm not really sure what they based this on. And yea, Alex Smith should be a lot higher than 10.


I'm sure 0421Kidwell could make a good ranking for you...but he might have to start a new thread for it.

[SmootSmack]

I think it's amazing how steveo395 aged 98 years in the matter of a few weeks and yet no one has brought it up

I also think this list is rather pointless, it's a list for the sake of having a list

[steveo395]

Originally Posted by TAFKAS

I think it's amazing how steveo395 aged 98 years in the matter of a few weeks and yet no one has brought it up

It's called talent, something you obviously don't have.

[Rexi]

Originally Posted by TAFKAS

I also think this list is rather pointless, it's a list for the sake of having a list

Yeah it is pointless but they made the list, so it's our job to berate them for it. Your thoughts would be appreciated.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by steveo395

It's called talent, something you obviously don't have.

Woe is me

[Rexi]

Originally Posted by steveo395

That list is pretty retarded. Jay Cutler hasn't taken a snap yet, Aaron Rodgers has barely played, Vince Young has been pretty crappy so far. Isn't this supposed to be a list of the top QBs 25 and under? This shouldn't be based on potential. I'm not really sure what they based this on. And yea, Alex Smith should be a lot higher than 10.


I'm sure 0421Kidwell could make a good ranking for you...but he might have to start a new thread for it.

LOL yeah I agree. I think Alex is #10 because some people still can't get their thick skulls around the 1-11 statistic.

[jamf]

I've been really impressed with alex smith. there are really only 5 QB's that have proven they can play.

I think Smith and Rivers tops in the group, they are also the guys with the least experience.

1 and 2: Smith and rivers
3: Roethlisberger
4: Schaub
5: Manning

[Rexi]

Originally Posted by jamf

I've been really impressed with alex smith. there are really only 5 QB's that have proven they can play.

I think Smith and Rivers tops in the group, they are also the guys with the least experience.

1 and 2: Smith and rivers
3: Roethlisberger
4: Schaub
5: Manning

I love you.

[0421kidwell]

eli is pretty good may be the skins should take a hint and play our young qb, they probably won't.37 yr old qb's rule!!

[Daseal]

As awful as big ben has been, how does he top that list.

Manning, Rivers, Smith, Leinart are the best ones that see the field. Vince Young prolly gets the #5 spot.

[hooskins]

kidwell would be proud of your personal rankings.

[Daseal]

Lol U Kant Ban Me Kan U!!!

[Rexi]

Originally Posted by Daseal

As awful as big ben has been, how does he top that list.

Manning, Rivers, Smith, Leinart are the best ones that see the field. Vince Young prolly gets the #5 spot.

Well he started the year badly obviously but he was having a nice game in ATL before he was concussed. And I guess a ring trumps all these guys at this point.

My revised Top 10

1.A.Smith
2.A.Smith
3.A.Smith
4.A.Smith
5.A.Smith
6.A.Smith
7.A.Smith
8.A.Smith
9.A.Smith
10.J.Campbell (Yeeha!)

[jamf]

Originally Posted by Rexi

I love you.

hmm so what are you wearing?