NFL Free Agency Around the League

[MTK]

This debate about whether Edelman belongs in the HOF or not is a little ridiculous. He's not a HOF'er and it's not even a close debate IMO.

[AnonEmouse]

Originally Posted by MTK

This debate about whether Edelman belongs in the HOF or not is a little ridiculous. He's not a HOF'er and it's not even a close debate IMO.

It's a debate. 3 SB rings, SB MVP, nearly as many postseason yards as Rice, arguably a key part of those multiple SB wins. Tough competitor. A lot of good traits.

I'm not saying its nailed on by any means, but Warner walked in with only 1 SB win and no all time statistical records (but yeah, 2 MVP, 4 Pro Bowl nods etc.). It's worthy of a debate but he's certainly not a 1st ballot consideration.

[skinsfan69]

Lately there have been people getting into the HOF that have been very good. It's all about politics now. John Lynch? Tom Flores? Neither are HOF'ers. Jim Covert over Jacoby is flat out laughable.

Julian E isn't a great player but he did it on the biggest stages. I just think his regular season numbers aren't strong enough.

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

Lately there have been people getting into the HOF that have been very good. It's all about politics now. John Lynch? Tom Flores? Neither are HOF'ers. Jim Covert over Jacoby is flat out laughable.

Julian E isn't a great player but he did it on the biggest stages. I just think his regular season numbers aren't strong enough.

Gary Clark should get in before Edelman.

10,000+ yards and 65 TDs with 2 SBs.

vs.

6,800 yards and 36 TDs.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by Monkeydad

Gary Clark should get in before Edelman.

10,000+ yards and 65 TDs with 2 SBs.

vs.

6,800 yards and 36 TDs.

Definitely!