Post Game Comments, And Then Some!

[That Guy]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

I like how people would rather rip Gibbs a new one than consider the possibility that he knows what he's doing with his own personel. The guy's one of the greatest coaches of all time. But hey, we have computers! We're qualified!

so we should shut down this site right now cause they're obviously no purpose for it right? because gibbs has NEVER made a mistake, EVER (cough, howard, cough), right? because he knows his personnel so well that their offseason upgrades have resulted in truely craptacular play on both sides of the ball, and that's how it should be, right? because waiting 9 games into 2004 with brunell was the right call, right? because those legendary half time adjustments are REALLY working out right now, right?

if gibbs has final say, he gets some responsibility for this monster. If something stupid happens, calling it out is fair game. none of these "you can't question gibbs" posts ever say you can't praise him for the good, just that you can't possibly ever say anything about the bad.

look, a lot of people here don't make movies, and they aren't musicians, but that doesn't mean they don't know crap when they hear it, or when they're forced to watch it. that's an extremely tired arguement that just doesn't hold up. yes, he's knowledgeable, yes, he'd had success, yes he's more qualified than any of us, BUT THAT DOES NOT MEAN he's always right. how many people here thought we needed a punter and cb depth? if gibbs is so much better than joe on the street at football and management, why didn't that get fixed? sometimes even the great ones fail to do the right thing.