Braylon Edwards trade talk

I think Edwards to the Giants is all but a lock (barring some last minute surprise like the Raiders swooping in), at which point SFRedskin will declare Edwards the greatest WR to ever don an NFL jersey

Actually that's when everyone will ride NY's jock(taking a break to get off of Philly's) about how great a FO they have.

Actually that's when everyone will ride NY's jock(taking a break to get off of Philly's) about how great a FO they have.Nope,everyone likes our FO now ...except for the bonehead move of a new stadium!

I think Edwards to the Giants is all but a lock (barring some last minute surprise like the Raiders swooping in), at which point SFRedskin will declare Edwards the greatest WR to ever don an NFL jerseyA few Giants fans I have talked to hate this idea. They would be willing to give up half of their draft pick for Boldin, but don't want to give up much for Edwards. The biggest reason I have heard is Edwards wants a new deal NOW. He wants huge money and IMO thats just not smart. How can you justify a Fitzgerald type deal for the guy who dropped more passes than anyone else in the league? He has always had bad hands and a simple change of scenery isnt going to help that.

Braylon? No way he ends up in DC.

Butter Fingers? LOL.

That says it all.

i cant believe you guys don't want Edwards? i don't , either. but when it comes to someone else's trash, we always seem to be first in line

i cant believe you guys don't want Edwards? i don't , either. but when it comes to someone else's trash, we always seem to be first in line
He is in his prime, wait 5 years and we'll give up multiple draft picks for him. LOL

Don't we already have wideouts that drop the ball?

Why would we want Rod Gardner part II?

Why would we want Rod Gardner part II?

understood about the drops, but Edwards has much more burst & speed, more athletic & gets open downfield. If his drops are a matter of concentration & focus, then it can be corrected. On the other hand, if he's dropping a lot cause he's not that comfortable in traffic (M. Westbrook comes to mind), his habit is likely to continue.

I certainly don't want edwards, especially w/our situation, give the young guys a chance. but at the right price he could be a serious playmaker for the right team. Hope he doesn't end up in the nfc east.