Should Billy Cundiff still be cut!

I'm hoping we go with Brown or Forbath. I liked what people here were saying about him a few pages back. Go young!

Kai Forbath | UCLA, K : 2011 NFL Draft Scout Player Profile (http://www.nfldraftscout.com/ratings/dsprofile.php?pyid=65127&draftyear=2011&genpos=K)

Forbath to me sounds worth a shot.

I agree 100%. With Brown and Mare we know what we'd be getting.

I'm hoping we go with Brown or Forbath. I liked what people here were saying about him a few pages back. Go young!

I'm 95% positive it's going to be Brown

It's not. Made the correction. The site he pulled it from still had his old contract listed.

ES source? sounds bout right

I"m with the others, I'd rather see what Forbath brings to the table. We are in the same situation with Brown that we were with Cundiff. Hoping he rebounds from a bad year.

I always thought Mare had a bit of a noodle leg. Not a lot of strength but accurate.

I could be totally wrong... Considering he's been out of the NFL for.. Oh, I dunno... About 2 years?

And he's 39.

forbath needs to show he can get the touchbacks. in his very small sample; he's about 22% (2/9 - doubt he attempted any onside kicks in preseason). no stiff competition from josh brown there...

since the rule change, brown is still only 28% (15/54 - not accounting for onside kicks)

olindo mare: 62% (53/84 - not accounting for onside kicks)

compare to cundiff: 59% (62/105 - not accounting for onside kicks)

While I wont miss the shoddy FGAs I certainly will miss being able to go get a drink on our kickoffs since Billy just crushed them consistently for no return. Our field position game may take a hit.

just looking at these numbers, who would you choose?

http://imageshack.us/a/img841/1766/kickercompare2.png

*edit, added a 6th kicker