Should Billy Cundiff still be cut!

IMO I don't think he saved his job be making that game winning field goal. If he had made the other 2 kicks (if you want to exclude the 57 yarder) then we would have been in a clock killing kneel down mode not scrambling to TRYING to win the game.

I would say give him another game, everybody has a bad day... With that said, I was ready to kill him on Sunday.... j/k

If there's someone out there on the street that could do a better job, he would probably be here already. Put kicker on the list for next offseason.

If he had missed that last kick, chances are he would have been gone.

He bought himself another week.

I dunno. If it wasn't for his kickoffs, I'd say that last kick didn't save him. It's just so hard to imagine someone missing every kick but one and still keeping their job.

He BARELY bought himself another week!

I just don't understand why they cut both Rackers and Gano for Cundiff. That simply makes 0 sense to me.

I just don't understand why they cut both Rackers and Gano for Cundiff. That simply makes 0 sense to me.

It's still a head scratcher. I mean, I like the fact that most of Cundiff's kick-offs are endzone bound, but in the grand scheme of things, you need a consistent field goal kicker.

If there's someone out there on the street that could do a better job, he would probably be here already. Put kicker on the list for next offseason.
If he had missed that last kick, chances are he would have been gone.

He bought himself another week.

Will do:

1. CornerBack
2. Right Tackle
3. Free Safety
4. Kicker

One week. It was one week. You cut a kicker for being bad...in general. One week really isn't enough to determine that he is bad. It really isn't. He misses any this week and I'd bet he's gone. But they should never cut a guy for one bad week.

I just don't understand why they cut both Rackers and Gano for Cundiff. That simply makes 0 sense to me.

It's not as if Gano or Rackers are in high demand. They're both sitting at home. I think you could flip a coin between all three and get similar production.