Redskins vs. Eagles predictions

[70Chip]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

Let's see. If Jason Campbell got us to three straight NFC Championship games, plus a Super Bowl would you be saying the same thing about him? I doubt it. Wasn't Mcnabb having a great year ( w/out TO ) last year before he got hurt? Doesn't McNabb have 153 TD's and 73 Ints and completes almost 60% of his passes? Plus he has great mobility that breaks the defense? C'mon. I know we all hate the Eagles but McNabb is a very very good QB.

Almost 60% is not elite in a west coast offense. He completed 54% before he got hurt again last year. If Jason Campbell lost all those big games, I think I, and many others, would be saying, "Jason Campbell can't win the big game." I don't understand the devotion of Redskins fans for this guy. The Eagles fans watch him every week and they don't feel this way about him. Donovan is a good quarterback who has been dinged up for the last three years. He and the offense he plays in lean heavily on the screen pass which pads his stats and doesn't require him to do much. He used to make a lot of plays with legs, now he sometimes makes plays with his arm. He's not now what he once was, and what he once was was not what some people think it was. I don't understand why Redskins fans have such an emotional attachment to a Philadelphia Eagle.