Russel Wilson or Bob

No doubt Wilson has more help

Let me ask you guys this.

Would Russel Wilson have led the Reskins the way RG III has? Does he have that leadership factor that we have with RG III?

He has the leadership skills equal to RGIII but not quite the physical skill set. Although close, I don't think his impact in Washington would have been as great.

I think Wilson would have been good in Washington, good players generally are good anywhere they go, it's the coaching and system that makes them elite IMO.

I don't think we will have a definite answer for at least 5 years, maybe 10. However after 10 we will def know which we would have rather had. I hope it's RG3, but for the picks at this point Wilson looks like a good option. I think RG3 is better and has a higher ceiling, but Wilson is very impressive

After finally seeing Wilson today, honestly Wilson seems like the real deal. Hard to believe Luck, RG3 and Wilson came from the same draft. Hindsight will tell us if all of these guys produce consistently over time - and Luck and RG3 seem less bust-proof. But Wilson cannot be playing any better tonight against one of the best defenses in the league. Three weeks of > 40-50 points is ridiculous.

Regardless, I think Washington DC needed the hype of RG3, his poise, personality and leadership. Shanahan's offensive schemes have maximized his production, and we're only going to see him mature as a passer as stated above.

In terms of rookie of the year -- I think RG3 may get it, but Luck / Wilson are right there.

I honestly think all three are equally deserving. Russel Wilson has been balling all season long. I wouldn't be the least upset if RG didn't get it. I just want him to take us deep into the playoffs.

HTTR 24-7 - NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: A Two Horse Race (http://httr24-7.com/blog/nfl-offensive-rookie-of-the-year-a-two-horse-race/)

I think IMO it is safe to say I rather Russell Wilson then Bob and 3 extra first round picks. I watched him for the first time last night for an entire game and I was very impressed.


Before you blast me I am not saying Wilson is better then RGIII; I am saying I rather Wilson and 3 first round picks (assuming we drafted Wilson in the 3rd round).

I think IMO it is safe to say I rather Russell Wilson then Bob and 3 extra first round picks. I watched him for the first time last night for an entire game and I was very impressed.


Before you blast me I am not saying Wilson is better then RGIII; I am saying I rather Wilson and 3 first round picks (assuming we drafted Wilson in the 3rd round).

No way man, I understand the picks but Griffin is a once in a decade player. Wilson is good but he's nothing special, in 5 years this discussion won't be close

No way man, I understand the picks but Griffin is a once in a decade player. Wilson is good but he's nothing special, in 5 years this discussion won't be close

Hmmm really? Wilson very well maybe a once in a decade player. Shoot Tom Brady is a once in decade player he was draft in the sixth round.

Right now as 12/24/2012 Wilson and RGIII are neck and neck quality wise.