|
mheisig 10-29-2007, 01:38 PM Okay let's be brutally honest for a minute, part of the issue, and correct me if wrong, is that we have a problem with Belichick as an individual and the perception we have him.
Secondly, if this were to happen at the amateur level, then I would lean on the side of calling character and class into question. But this is professional sports. Why is that important to consider here? Because we invest so much of our time and money looking for the best and the brightest. Drilling it into our kids from the time they can run and compete, "win at all costs" Give one hundred percent...leave it on the field. Well, the Pats have a higher standard for those cliches.
You see in the end, we want it both ways. We love to hear at the end of the big games, "no one deserved it more than so and so". But see, that's not the real world. Sometimes classy people win, and I'm okay with that. And sometimes assholes win and win big, and I'm okay with that too. To me "running up the score" isn't the big deal. As long as he wasn't intentionally cheating or trying to injure someone, then I'm okay with that. His eleven guys pushed our eleven guys back for 60 minutes. What's the problem?
Not that this is the point of the post or thread, but "win at all costs" is not what I'm teaching my kids.
I think your point about Belichick being and asshole and winning is absolutely right. I guess we just take it differently when an asshole wins. I agree, assholes win all the time, they succeed, make money, get famous and so on. That doesn't mean I like it or am ok with it. I like to see "good" guys like Peyton Manning and Tony Dungy or Joe Gibbs win, and who wouldn't?
I think it's an almost universal thing to want to see "good" people thrive and see the "evil" people fail. Doesn't always happen like that, but that doesn't mean I'm not pissed off, and rightly so, when a prick like Belichick not only wins, but makes it a point to humiliate his opponents at every turn.
GhettoDogAllStars 10-29-2007, 01:41 PM Regarding assholes who win and/or succeed:
It comes down to one thing in my mind: life isn't fair, but that is no reason why it shouldn't be. When a child says, "that's no fair," a typical adult response is, "life's not fair." That is fallacious reasoning, and a totally worthless argument.
skinsfan69 10-29-2007, 01:42 PM Have you decided not to get married because you know you would do the same as your friends, and you don't want to be like that?
I'm not even sure why this interests me. I'm just curious to know why someone would say it's ok for their married friends (who are also fathers correct?) to cheat? But at the same time you don't condone cheating.
Um.. I think that's part of it. I don't want to cheat on my wife and I know I'm a little weak when it comes to women. And I certainly don't want to hurt anybody. I use to date someone for several years and I cheated and she found out about it. I'll never ever forget how I hurt this person. So I just have chosen not to do it yet. Am I a bad guy? No. I'm a nice guy and a good person who has a weakness for women. At least I can admit it
I never said it is ok for my married friends to cheat. It's not OK. I just don't judge their character because they choose to cheat.
12thMan 10-29-2007, 01:44 PM Not that this is the point of the post or thread, but "win at all costs" is not what I'm teaching my kids.
I think your point about Belichick being and asshole and winning is absolutely right. I guess we just take it differently when an asshole wins. I agree, assholes win all the time, they succeed, make money, get famous and so on. That doesn't mean I like it or am ok with it. I like to see "good" guys like Peyton Manning and Tony Dungy or Joe Gibbs win, and who wouldn't?
I think it's an almost universal thing to want to see "good" people thrive and see the "evil" people fail. Doesn't always happen like that, but that doesn't mean I'm not pissed off, and rightly so, when a prick like Belichick not only wins, but makes it a point to humiliate his opponents at every turn.
Agreed.
mheisig 10-29-2007, 01:45 PM Um.. I think that's part of it. I don't want to cheat on my wife and I know I'm a little weak when it comes to women. And I certainly don't want to hurt anybody. I use to date someone for several years and I cheated and she found out about it. I'll never ever forget how I hurt this person. So I just have chosen not to do it yet. Am I a bad guy? No. I'm a nice guy and a good person who has a weakness for women. At least I can admit it
I never said it is ok for my married friends to cheat. It's not OK. I just don't judge their character because they choose to cheat.
If you don't judge a person's character by their actions, particular whether they cheat or not, than what the hell DO you judge their character by? Or do you just arbitrarily determine that someone is a "good person" and stick with that notion regardless of the facts of their actions?
Southpaw 10-29-2007, 01:51 PM If you don't judge a person's character by their actions, particular whether they cheat or not, than what the hell DO you judge their character by? Or do you just arbitrarily determine that someone is a "good person" and stick with that notion regardless of the facts of their actions?
Cheat's on his wife and lies to his family... Eh, he's still a good guy in my book.
Cheat's in a poker game or doesn't pay back the $20 he borrowed last week... Eff that sorry Effer!
But to tie it back to Belichick; does a guy being a good football coach outweigh the fact that he's a scumbag?
irish 10-29-2007, 01:56 PM Not that this is the point of the post or thread, but "win at all costs" is not what I'm teaching my kids.
I think your point about Belichick being and asshole and winning is absolutely right. I guess we just take it differently when an asshole wins. I agree, assholes win all the time, they succeed, make money, get famous and so on. That doesn't mean I like it or am ok with it. I like to see "good" guys like Peyton Manning and Tony Dungy or Joe Gibbs win, and who wouldn't?
I think it's an almost universal thing to want to see "good" people thrive and see the "evil" people fail. Doesn't always happen like that, but that doesn't mean I'm not pissed off, and rightly so, when a prick like Belichick not only wins, but makes it a point to humiliate his opponents at every turn.
I dont think A-holes win all the time. They win & lose like everyone else. Also, are you saying BB is evil? Thats a stretch if I ever heard one. A-hole and evil are not synonyms.
SmootSmack 10-29-2007, 01:56 PM Um.. I think that's part of it. I don't want to cheat on my wife and I know I'm a little weak when it comes to women. And I certainly don't want to hurt anybody. I use to date someone for several years and I cheated and she found out about it. I'll never ever forget how I hurt this person. So I just have chosen not to do it yet. Am I a bad guy? No. I'm a nice guy and a good person who has a weakness for women. At least I can admit it
I never said it is ok for my married friends to cheat. It's not OK. I just don't judge their character because they choose to cheat.
Fair enough. Not to get too deep here, but as a real friend do you think you have any obligation to be honest with your friends is wrong? That they're potentially destroying their families?
Big C 10-29-2007, 02:03 PM why were they going for it on 4th down? thats my only problem really
DEVIL'S OWN 10-29-2007, 02:08 PM want all yall shut up about moral........i dont give a shit about who sleeping with who, we got our ass kicked......and if it bothers you............deal with it.....do what i do, i went out last night and cheated on my wife and girlfriend. now im have to explain to both when i get home
|