30gut
10-28-2009, 01:30 PM
So who will be your poison?
It fitting that you choose the word poison because drafting a QB with an early round draft pick is a mistake in my opinion.
We need our top picks for OL.
But i'll stick with your OP though....
If the Skins must draft a QB i would hope that Tebow/McCoy falls into the 2-3rd rounds.
Monkeydad
10-28-2009, 01:40 PM
Depending on who the coach is, there's a chance JC stays. Just saying.
Agreed. He's playing extremely well CONSIDERING he has zero protection and is running for his life. Heck, he doesn't even have a center that can snap the ball properly...no QB could succeed with this line, or lack of one.
I think he has showed a lot of progress and even leadership, but no captain can save a sinking ship...he can only hope to keep it above water as long as possible. Look at the second half drives against Philly, with Campbell obviously hurting (ankle) from taking so many shots. He put together some great drives that would have resulted in 2 TDs and an impressive comeback if Rabach wasn't such a...
I want Campbell back with a built-up line and new coach. I believe he'll do extremely well. Our top pick must be used on the best tackle in the nation.
Monkeydad
10-28-2009, 01:46 PM
ewww, i disagree... im thinking he might be a great fit.. at least he can outrun the rush we see every attempt! just my opinion... bring on tebow!! thats my .02
If we waste our 1st round pick on a QB, especially Tebow, he'll need to be able to run for his life after another year of neglecting the line in the draft.
GTripp0012
10-28-2009, 01:47 PM
In terms of veterans, I like the idea of getting Bulger. He's on a horrible team, but the man has talent.You could just replace "Bulger" with "Campbell" and the argument fits just as well.
We'd still have to fix the obvious issues with the offense before you could sap one ounce of Bulgers talent, and at that point, you're still not getting anything you wouldn't have with Campbell.
SFREDSKIN
10-28-2009, 01:49 PM
Agreed. He's playing extremely well CONSIDERING he has zero protection and is running for his life. Heck, he doesn't even have a center that can snap the ball properly...no QB could succeed with this line, or lack of one.
I think he has showed a lot of progress and even leadership, but no captain can save a sinking ship...he can only hope to keep it above water as long as possible. Look at the second half drives against Philly, with Campbell obviously hurting (ankle) from taking so many shots. He put together some great drives that would have resulted in 2 TDs and an impressive comeback if Rabach wasn't such a...
I want Campbell back with a built-up line and new coach. I believe he'll do extremely well. Our top pick must be used on the best tackle in the nation.
This is what I've been saying and makes the most sense. Do people want some inexperience backup to run the team? I don't, I rather take my chances rebuilding the line and see how Campbell performs under it. This would only happens if Campbell wants to return after all the crap he's been thrown at.
SmootSmack
10-28-2009, 01:53 PM
It probably makes more sense to go OL first round and then maybe QB in the second (especially with the depth there in this year's draft). And then OL again in the mid to late rounds.
But I don't see it as a total tragedy if we draft a QB first and then go OL in the 2nd
skinsfan69
10-28-2009, 02:06 PM
You could just replace "Bulger" with "Campbell" and the argument fits just as well.
We'd still have to fix the obvious issues with the offense before you could sap one ounce of Bulgers talent, and at that point, you're still not getting anything you wouldn't have with Campbell.
Well you'd have to fix the o-line but Bulger is a more accurate passer than JC. He doesn't have the physical skills, arm mobility and so on... but I think he can be a better QB with a good team around him. Bulger does something I've never ever seen JC do in 5 years, he actually throws the ball before wr's come out of their breaks.
skinsfan69
10-28-2009, 02:09 PM
Both guys?
I'm just throwing things around. We've got to upgrade the QB position and I don't see a can't miss prospect coming out in the draft.
skinsfan69
10-28-2009, 02:12 PM
Colt McCoy reminds me of Heath Shuler.
Monkeydad
10-28-2009, 02:22 PM
Well you'd have to fix the o-line but Bulger is a more accurate passer than JC. He doesn't have the physical skills, arm mobility and so on... but I think he can be a better QB with a good team around him. Bulger does something I've never ever seen JC do in 5 years, he actually throws the ball before wr's come out of their breaks.
trZfHoEtFeE